Most of us have issued our winter outlooks and so it is now my turn. Long range forecasting is as much an art as it is a science. We all have a bias of some kind whether it be warm or cold, lots of snow or little snow. If we look hard enough we can find evidence to support our forecast. I've seen a couple of cold and snowy projections. Now you will see one that is a little different.
Winter Outlook for December 2012- February 2013
Prepared by: Meteorologist Andy Weingarten
Introduction:
Most of the country was warmer than normal this summer and there were large areas of drought to help it along. Drought conditions have improved significantly this fall and that has led to some downward trend in temperature anomalies the past 2 months. This rain largely occurred without impact from the tropics. This will be the second winter to use the new 1981-2010 30 year baseline for normal temperatures. These are in many cases warmer than the 1971-2000 normal. In theory it will be easier to get below normal than in past winters, but it did not result in that last year which was quite warm. El Nino has been predicted to be a driver this winter, but its development has not been as robust as expected.
I issued a 20 page outlook for my private clients, much too long to bring here. So, I will simply show my highlights. The El Nino has not developed as expected earlier this year. That would have been a major bullish signal for a cold winter extending what has been a cool Autumn. The average of all El Nino forecasts here show a neutral state.
Most forecasters love to look at the NAO/AO in the winter. These are pressure patterns in the Atlantic which indicate things such as wind direction and speed of movement of large systems. In the negative phase in winter it is often cold and snowy. We have been in a negative phase much of the fall and may continue a while longer but clearly December is not starting cold. In fact, it looks warm the next two weeks. Here is the NAO/AO outlook and look back. Keep in mind predictions for this are not reliable more than a week or two out.
Despite the consistently negative values , December will start warm here.
Finally many meteorologists use an analog method. That means look at years past with similar characteristics to get a glimpse of the future. There are many numerical values one can use. I normally use the QBO and the PDO.
The first one is known as the Quasi Biennial Oscillation (QBO). This is a measurement of wind direction in the Tropical Pacific. These winds have been from the east consistently over the last two years representing a negative phase. There is a chart of these measurements located at http://www.cdc.noaa.gov/Correlation/qbo.data. This consistency made it easier to find recent 1-2 year periods that have been consistently negative. I found a number of years that qualified. Keep in mind that any analog method used only assumes that piece of data as a factor. It is why they often do not play a big role in my forecast preparation unless I think it is a main driver. Here is what those winters look like.
The second analog is called the Pacific Decadal Oscillation (PDO). This is a Northern Pacific Sea surface measurement. It has similarities to the El Niño/La Niña phenomenon but on a longer time scale. Most observations indicate long term we are in a decade of negative phase indicative of colder temperatures. The index has also been weakly negative for the last two years. I looked for years with similar trends and came up with the following.
If you can find a match between the two that can lend more confidence to the methodology. I found a match the winter of 1999 that is similar to both. Manyof you will not like the result.
That is a warm winter folks! I am not going as warm as last years 4.3 above normal or as snowless as the 7" we saw. But I am thinking 2-3 above normal and 12-15 inches of snow. I do not expect to see frequent winter storms, but in our area the normal snow for a winter is around 20". Two or three modest events and a handful of the 1" snows we commonly see would be enough to get to my forecast.
- Sea Surface Temperatures… This is becoming a more useful tool in seasonal forecasting and not just in the tropical Pacific with respect to ENSO. If El Nino were developing we would see a lot more warm temperatures off the South American coastline near the equator. There is some, but the warmer anomalies are north between 30 and 40 N latitude and close to the U.S. coastlines. The Atlantic in particular is warm which may make it very difficult for the east coast to see a below normal winter, but easier over the Plains.
The second analog is called the Pacific Decadal Oscillation (PDO). This is a Northern Pacific Sea surface measurement. It has similarities to the El Niño/La Niña phenomenon but on a longer time scale. Most observations indicate long term we are in a decade of negative phase indicative of colder temperatures. The index has also been weakly negative for the last two years. I looked for years with similar trends and came up with the following.
There are a number of changes here, less cold and farther east. If I can find a match between these, that is always helpful and this year I did. The 98-99 winter shows up in both and looked like this.
Now that was a warm winter!
Finally I show last years’ winter map which was warmer than normal for a large part of the country.
6... Time to draw some conclusions:
There is more than average uncertainty in my outlook this year. There are some elements to suggest going cold such as the potential for more frequent negative NAO/AO signatures and the lack of the forecasted El Nino. Some of the global models also project some cold. On the other hand sea surface temperatures and analog methods are suggestive of another warm winter. I would think it would be unlikely to see the type of warmth we had last year but then the best analog year I found was even warmer. The El Nino could have been the pattern changer and without it there are a lot of similarities globally to last year. Given that, I am leaning warm. I am actually most confident this winter on the warmth in the NE and the slight chill in the NW. Here is an approximation of what I think winter 2012-13 will look like.


